Key takeaways
- Compare the best bike pedals for trail, commuting, and road riding, from SPD clipless models to wide flat platforms, with specs to help you choose.
Short Answer
The best bike pedals depend on how you ride. For trail and cross-country riding with clipless shoes, the Shimano PD-M520 is the proven budget SPD pick, with a double-sided mechanism and adjustable release tension. For flat-pedal trail riding, the RaceFace Chester and the OneUp Components Composite Pedal lead on platform size and grip, while the ROCKBROS K203-BK covers the same flat-pedal ground at a budget tier. For riders who switch between clipless shoes and ordinary shoes, the Shimano PD-M324 is the dual-sided answer, with an SPD mechanism on one side and a flat platform on the other.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Table of Contents
- Short Answer
- How to Choose Bike Pedals
- 1. Shimano PD-M520 SPD Pedals
- 2. RaceFace Chester Flat Pedals
- 3. OneUp Components Composite Pedals
- 4. ROCKBROS K203-BK Aluminum Flat Pedals
- 5. Shimano PD-M324 Dual-Sided Pedals
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion
How to Choose Bike Pedals
Start with the pedal type. Flat pedals, also called platform pedals, accept any shoe and let the rider lift a foot instantly, which suits technical trail riding, commuting, and riders who are still building confidence. Clipless pedals, such as Shimano SPD models, lock a cleat on the shoe into the pedal mechanism, which keeps the foot planted and lets the rider pull up as well as push down. Dual-sided pedals combine both, with a clipless mechanism on one face and a flat platform on the other.
Next, check the spindle thread. Almost every modern adult bike uses a 9/16-inch spindle, and all five pedals in this guide use that standard. Older one-piece cranks on some cruisers and children’s bikes use a 1/2-inch thread instead, so confirm the crank before ordering.
Platform size matters for flat pedals. A larger platform spreads pressure across the shoe and gives more support on rough ground, while a smaller platform saves weight and reduces pedal strikes on tight trails. Pin count and pin height decide grip: more pins and taller pins hold the shoe harder, but they also make foot repositioning slower and increase the chance of scraped shins.
For clipless pedals, check cleat compatibility and float. Shimano SPD pedals use a two-bolt cleat, and the SM-SH51 single-release cleat ships with both Shimano picks in this guide. SPD mechanisms offer about four degrees of float, which is the small amount of sideways heel movement allowed before the cleat releases.
1. Shimano PD-M520 SPD Pedals
The Shimano PD-M520 is the long-running budget SPD pedal, first released in 2004 and still listed as a current model more than two decades later. It is a double-sided clipless pedal, so the rider can clip in from either side without flipping the pedal, which makes it forgiving at traffic lights and on technical climbs. The mechanism uses the two-bolt SPD system with SM-SH51 cleats included in the box, and the spring tension is adjustable, so a new clipless rider can set a light release and tighten it as confidence grows. Construction is straightforward and durable: a chromoly steel axle, sealed cartridge bearings, and a compact body. The black version covered here carries ASIN B000KC3Y0G under model PDM520L, while the silver version is a separate listing under a different ASIN, so match the black color and the ASIN together.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Type | SPD clipless, double-sided |
| Model | PDM520L |
| ASIN | B000KC3Y0G |
| Spindle | 9/16 inch, chromoly steel |
| Bearings | Sealed cartridge |
| Cleats included | SM-SH51, single-release |
| Float | 4 degrees |
| Release tension | Adjustable |
| Weight | 378 g per pair |
| Tier | Budget |
2. RaceFace Chester Flat Pedals
The RaceFace Chester is the benchmark nylon composite flat pedal, and it has held that position for years because it balances platform size, grip, and weight at a mid-range tier. The platform measures 110 by 101 millimeters, with a concave shape that cups the shoe, and the body is nylon composite rather than alloy, which keeps the weight down to 360 grams per pair while shrugging off rock strikes that would dent a metal pedal. Grip comes from 16 replaceable hex traction pins per pedal, eight on each side, and inside the pedal sealed cartridge bearings pair with a DU bushing for water resistance and full serviceability.
A small specification conflict is worth noting. Some retailers list the platform as 101 by 110 millimeters, which is the same pair of numbers in the opposite order, so the platform itself is consistent. A separate conflict concerns the pin count: some roundups describe 16 pins per side, but RaceFace’s own specification is 16 pins per pedal, eight per side, and this guide follows the maker’s figure. The Chester is available in nine colors, and each color is a separate listing, so match the black colorway and ASIN B018J1J7QE together.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Type | Flat platform, nylon composite |
| Model | PD16CHEBLK |
| ASIN | B018J1J7QE |
| Platform | 110 x 101 mm |
| Body height | 18.4 mm |
| Pins | 16 per pedal, 8 per side, replaceable |
| Axle | Chromoly steel, 9/16 inch |
| Bearings | Sealed cartridge with DU bushing |
| Weight | 360 g per pair |
| Warranty | 2-year manufacturer warranty |
| Tier | Mid-range |
3. OneUp Components Composite Pedals
The OneUp Components Composite Pedal is the premium flat pick in this guide, built around a very large platform and a thin profile. The platform measures 115 by 105 millimeters, which is larger than the Chester in both directions, and the thin leading edge is chamfered to deflect off trail obstacles and reduce pedal strikes. The body uses fiber-reinforced nylon composite, which keeps the weight to 355 grams per pair despite the larger footprint.
Grip comes from ten rear-loading steel pins per side, secured with Nyloc nuts, and the pedal has a subtle convex profile that sits in the natural arch of the foot. The axle system pairs a DU bushing with a cartridge bearing, and the chromoly spindle uses the standard 9/16-inch thread.
The black version covered here carries ASIN B074Q41G3Y under part number 1C0399BLK. Other colors, including orange and green, are separate listings with their own ASINs, so confirm the black colorway when ordering.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Type | Flat platform, composite |
| Model | 1C0399BLK |
| ASIN | B074Q41G3Y |
| Platform | 115 x 105 mm |
| Pins | 10 per side, rear-loading steel |
| Axle | Chromoly steel, 9/16 inch |
| Bearings | DU bushing plus cartridge bearing |
| Weight | 355 g per pair |
| Tier | Premium |
4. ROCKBROS K203-BK Aluminum Flat Pedals
The ROCKBROS K203-BK is the budget flat pedal in this guide, and it is the only alloy-bodied pick here. The body is CNC-machined aluminum alloy, which gives a harder, more precise platform than nylon composite, and the pedal runs on sealed bearings with a chromoly steel axle. The spindle is the standard 9/16 inch, and the pedal fits road, mountain, BMX, and fixie bikes.
The flat platform carries anti-slip pins and a textured surface, and the left and right pedals are marked L and R for installation. The K203-BK is sold by ROCKBROS USA and ships as a pair, and its part number and model number are both K203-BK, which makes it easy to match the listing.
Buyers should be careful about ROCKBROS naming. The brand sells several flat pedals with similar titles, including a nylon fiber version and a dual-function SPD version, and each is a separate listing. The K203-BK covered here is the aluminum flat pedal, and its ASIN is B08FFHW2PV with UPC 873377706123.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Type | Flat platform, aluminum alloy |
| Model | K203-BK |
| ASIN | B08FFHW2PV |
| Body | CNC aluminum alloy |
| Axle | Chromoly steel, 9/16 inch |
| Bearings | Sealed bearing |
| Installation | Left and right marked L and R |
| UPC | 873377706123 |
| Tier | Budget |
5. Shimano PD-M324 Dual-Sided Pedals
The Shimano PD-M324 is the dual-sided pick in this guide, and it solves the most common pedal dilemma: one bike, two kinds of shoes. One side of each pedal carries an SPD clipless mechanism, and the other side is a flat platform, so the rider can clip in with SPD shoes for a long ride or hop on in ordinary shoes for a short trip without changing pedals. It is a popular choice for commuting, touring, and indoor cycling bikes, where the rider may not always wear cycling shoes.
The SPD side uses the same two-bolt system as the PD-M520, with SM-SH51 cleats included, and the flat side gives a stable platform for casual shoes. The axle is chromoly steel with a 9/16-inch thread, and the model number is EPDM324. Shimano lists the weight at 533 grams per pair, which makes the M324 the heaviest pedal in this guide, and that weight is the price of carrying two pedal types in one body.
The PD-M324 is a long-running model, and its listing has been live for many years, so buyers should confirm that the listing is orderable before planning around it. The ASIN covered here is B000NORMU4 with UPC 689228072466.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Type | Dual-sided, SPD clipless and flat |
| Model | EPDM324 |
| ASIN | B000NORMU4 |
| Spindle | 9/16 inch, chromoly steel |
| Cleats included | SM-SH51, single-release |
| Float | 4 degrees |
| Weight | 533 g per pair |
| UPC | 689228072466 |
| Tier | Mid-range |
Frequently Asked Questions
Are flat pedals or clipless pedals better for beginners?
Flat pedals are usually the better starting point. They accept any shoe, and the rider can lift a foot off instantly, which builds confidence on technical ground and in traffic. Clipless pedals reward the rider with a locked-in connection and more efficient power transfer, but they need compatible shoes and a short learning period for clipping in and out.
Do all of these pedals fit a standard bike?
All five pedals in this guide use a 9/16-inch spindle thread, which fits almost every modern adult bike. The exception is older one-piece cranks found on some cruisers and children’s bikes, which use a 1/2-inch thread. Check the crank before ordering, because a 9/16-inch pedal will not thread into a 1/2-inch crank.
What is the difference between SPD and SPD-SL pedals?
SPD is Shimano’s two-bolt system for mountain, gravel, and touring shoes, with a small recessed cleat that allows walking. SPD-SL is Shimano’s three-bolt road system, with a larger cleat that is not recessed and is designed for road shoes. The SPD pedals in this guide, the PD-M520 and the PD-M324, use two-bolt SPD cleats and do not accept SPD-SL cleats.
How often should bike pedals be serviced?
Service intervals depend on riding conditions. Pedals ridden in mud, rain, and grit need cleaning and fresh grease more often than pedals used only on dry roads. Sealed cartridge bearings resist contamination well, but they still wear, and pins should be checked for bending and replaced when they no longer grip.
Conclusion
The best bike pedals are the ones that match the riding. The Shimano PD-M520 is the budget SPD pick for trail and cross-country riders who want a proven clipless pedal with adjustable release tension. The RaceFace Chester and the OneUp Components Composite Pedal are the flat-pedal leaders, with the Chester offering the best balance of size, grip, and weight at a mid-range tier and the OneUp offering the largest platform and the lightest weight at a premium tier. The ROCKBROS K203-BK covers flat-pedal riding at a budget tier with a CNC aluminum body. And the Shimano PD-M324 is the dual-sided answer for riders who switch between clipless shoes and ordinary shoes on the same bike.
|—|—|
| Shimano PD-M520 SPD Pedals | ⚠ B000KC3Y0G |
| RaceFace Chester Flat Pedals | ⚠ B018J1J7QE |
You might also like
- Best Bike Grips for Trail, Touring, and Commuting 2026
- Best Bike Bottle Cages for Road and Trail Rides 2026
- Best Bike Bells: 5 Picks for Commuting and Trails 2026
- Best Bike Trunk Bags for Commuting and Touring 2026
- Best Bike Saddle Covers: 5 Gel Picks for Comfort 2026
- Best Bike Wall Mounts for Garages and Apartments 2026