Key takeaways
- Compare five dog treats for training, everyday rewards and dental care, from crunchy Milk-Bone biscuits to soft Zuke's bites and Greenies chews.
Dog treats do more than make a tail wag. The right treat speeds up training, gives a puppy something to work for, and turns a quiet afternoon into a small celebration. The wrong treat can be too hard for a small mouth, too big to use as a quick reward, or full of ingredients that do not suit a sensitive stomach.
This guide compares five treats that cover those jobs.
Short Answer: For most dogs, the best all-round pick is Zuke’s Mini Naturals in Chicken, a soft, small bite for training and everyday rewards. Milk-Bone Original Biscuits are the best budget pick, Blue Buffalo BLUE Bits are the best value training treat, Merrick Power Bites are the best grain-free option, and Greenies Original Regular is the best dental chew here.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Table of Contents
- How to Choose a Dog Treat
- Milk-Bone Original Dog Treats Biscuits, Medium
- Blue Buffalo BLUE Bits Beef Recipe
- Zuke’s Mini Naturals Chicken Recipe
- Merrick Power Bites Chicken Recipe
- Greenies Original Regular Dental Treats
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion
How to Choose a Dog Treat
Start with size. Milk-Bone sizes its biscuits by dog weight, with the medium biscuit made for dogs over 20 pounds. Training treats such as BLUE Bits and Zuke’s Mini Naturals are deliberately small, so a dog can eat one quickly and get back to work. Match the treat to the mouth, and break larger treats into pieces when a session calls for many rewards.
Next, think about texture. Crunchy biscuits suit dogs that like to chew and work well as an everyday reward between meals. Soft and moist treats suit training, because the dog can eat them fast and stay focused, and they also suit older dogs and puppies with tender mouths.
Then read the ingredients with your dog’s stomach in mind. Some treats list a named meat first, such as real beef or real chicken, while others start with flour or meal. Grain-free treats suit dogs that do not tolerate wheat or corn, but grain-free is not automatically better for every dog. Greenies, for example, are built on wheat flour and wheat gluten, so they do not suit a dog with a wheat sensitivity.
Also check the bag size and the count. Multi-packs and larger boxes are usually separate listings, so confirm the exact size and flavor together when you order. Finally, keep treats in proportion. A widely repeated veterinary guideline is that treats should make up no more than about a tenth of a dog’s daily calories.
Milk-Bone Original Dog Treats Biscuits, Medium
Milk-Bone Original Biscuits are the classic dog treat. The medium biscuit in the 24-ounce box is made for dogs over 20 pounds, and it is the crunchy, bone-shaped biscuit that many owners grew up giving their dogs.
The biscuit is beef flavored and baked with 12 vitamins and minerals. Milk-Bone lists the treats as made in the USA, and the maker is the J.M. Smucker Company, which has produced Milk-Bone biscuits in Buffalo, New York. The model number for this listing is 079100772728, and the UPC is 079100514106. The listing first appeared on April 10, 2013.
Crunch is the point here, and it is also the limit. A crunchy biscuit cleans up easily. But a dog with sore teeth, missing teeth, or a very small mouth will struggle with a hard biscuit. Milk-Bone sells small and large biscuits under separate listings, so match the size to the dog.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Product | Milk-Bone Original Dog Treats Biscuits, Medium |
| ASIN | B007V9VQ06 |
| Form | Crunchy biscuit |
| Flavor | Beef |
| Bag size | 24 ounces |
| Size | Medium, for dogs over 20 pounds |
| Model number | 079100772728 |
| UPC | 079100514106 |
| First available | April 10, 2013 |
| Vitamins and minerals | 12 |
| Made in | USA |
| Treat count per box | Not stated |
Blue Buffalo BLUE Bits Beef Recipe
BLUE Bits are Blue Buffalo’s training treat, and the beef recipe in the 4-ounce bag is the value training pick in this guide. The treats are heart-shaped, bite-sized, and soft and moist, so a dog can eat one in a second and stay focused on the next command.
Real beef is the first ingredient, and the recipe includes DHA, which Blue Buffalo lists as supporting cognitive development. The treats contain no chicken by-product meals, corn, wheat, or soy. Blue Buffalo describes BLUE Bits as suitable for dogs of all life stages, from puppies to seniors,
The model number for this listing is 803831, and it first appeared on May 20, 2013. Blue Buffalo also sells an 11-ounce bag and a to-go pack, both under separate listings. Watch the flavor when you order: the salmon recipe carries an “Is Discontinued By Manufacturer” field in one listing crawl, so the beef recipe covered here is the safer choice.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Product | Blue Buffalo BLUE Bits, Beef Recipe |
| ASIN | B00CW4QKZQ |
| Form | Soft, moist heart-shaped bites |
| Flavor | Beef |
| Bag size | 4 ounces |
| First ingredient | Real beef |
| DHA | Yes |
| Free from | Chicken by-product meals, corn, wheat, soy |
| Life stage | All life stages |
| Model number | 803831 |
| First available | May 20, 2013 |
| Calories per treat | Not stated |
Zuke’s Mini Naturals Chicken Recipe
Zuke’s Mini Naturals are the best all-round pick in this guide. The chicken recipe in the 16-ounce resealable pouch is a soft, chewy training treat made with real chicken, and the bites are small enough for dogs of all sizes.
The pouch is resealable, which keeps soft bites from drying out. The model number for this listing is 33021, and the UPC is 613423000191.
Flavor matters more than usual with Zuke’s, because not every flavor is easy to find. The salmon recipe in the 16-ounce pouch and the beef recipe in the 6-ounce bag both showed “No featured offers available” in listing crawls, which means those listings may not be orderable when you check. The chicken recipe covered here is the one to buy.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Product | Zuke’s Mini Naturals, Chicken Recipe |
| ASIN | B000H0ZJHW |
| Form | Soft, chewy bites |
| Flavor | Chicken |
| Bag size | 16 ounces, resealable pouch |
| First ingredient | Real chicken |
| Model number | 33021 |
| UPC | 613423000191 |
| Maker | Merrick Pet Care |
| Suitable for | Dogs of all sizes |
| Calories per treat | Not stated |
Merrick Power Bites Chicken Recipe
Merrick Power Bites are the grain-free pick in this guide. The chicken recipe in the 6-ounce bag is a soft and chewy, star-shaped treat made with real deboned chicken as the first ingredient. The star shape splits cleanly for a small mouth.
The recipe is grain-free and cooked in the USA, and the treats are marketed for dogs of every size. The model number is 78510, and the listing first appeared on March 27, 2014. At 6 ounces, the bag is smaller than the Zuke’s pouch, so heavy trainers will go through it faster.
The main caveat is the same as with Zuke’s: check the flavor. The salmon recipe showed “No featured offers available” in a listing crawl, so the chicken recipe covered here is the reliable choice. Merrick also sells beef and turducken recipes under separate listings. Power Bites sit at the premium end of this guide, and the reason is the ingredient list: real deboned chicken first, no grains, and a short list of added minerals.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Product | Merrick Power Bites, Chicken Recipe |
| ASIN | B00JAEKBGA |
| Form | Soft and chewy star-shaped bites |
| Flavor | Chicken |
| Bag size | 6 ounces, resealable bag |
| First ingredient | Real deboned chicken |
| Grain-free | Yes |
| Model number | 78510 |
| First available | March 27, 2014 |
| Made in | USA |
| Suitable for | Dogs of every size |
| Protein content | Not stated |
Greenies Original Regular Dental Treats
Greenies Original Regular is the dental chew in this guide, and it is also a daily reward. The 27-ounce pack holds 27 treats, one for each day of the month, and the regular size is made for dogs weighing 25 to 50 pounds.
The chew is built on wheat flour, glycerin, wheat gluten, gelatin, and powdered cellulose, with natural poultry flavor and added vitamins and minerals. That wheat base is the main thing to check before you buy: a dog with a wheat sensitivity should not eat Greenies. The treats carry the Veterinary Oral Health Council seal of acceptance. The model number for this listing is 10123686.
Size is everything with Greenies, because the chew needs to match the dog’s weight to work as intended. The regular size covers 25 to 50 pounds. Teenie, Petite, and Large sizes are separate listings. Other pack counts are separate listings.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Product | Greenies Original Regular Natural Dental Dog Treats |
| ASIN | B000KEVF32 |
| Form | Dental chew |
| Flavor | Original |
| Pack size | 27 ounces, 27 treats |
| Size | Regular, for dogs 25 to 50 pounds |
| Feeding guide | One treat per day |
| VOHC accepted | Yes |
| Main ingredients | Wheat flour, glycerin, wheat gluten, gelatin |
| Model number | 10123686 |
| Calories per treat | Not stated |
Frequently Asked Questions
How many treats can I give my dog each day?
A widely repeated veterinary guideline is that treats should make up no more than about a tenth of a dog’s daily calories. It matters most with larger treats, which carry more calories per piece than a tiny training bite. If your dog is gaining weight, the treats are the first thing to check.
Are soft treats or crunchy biscuits better for training?
Soft treats are better for training, because the dog eats them in a second and stays focused on the next command. BLUE Bits, Zuke’s Mini Naturals, and Merrick Power Bites are all soft for that reason.
Can puppies eat the treats in this guide?
It depends on the treat. BLUE Bits and Zuke’s Mini Naturals suit dogs of all life stages and sizes, including puppies. Milk-Bone medium biscuits are made for dogs over 20 pounds, so a small puppy should get the small size instead. Greenies are sized by weight, so a puppy needs the size that matches its current weight, not its adult weight.
Do dental treats replace brushing my dog’s teeth?
No. A dental chew such as Greenies helps clean teeth and freshen breath, and it carries the Veterinary Oral Health Council seal of acceptance, but it does not replace brushing. Brushing removes plaque from the gum line in a way chewing cannot match. Think of a dental chew as a daily helper between brushings, not as a substitute for them.
Conclusion
The best dog treat is the one that fits the job, the dog, and the stomach. Zuke’s Mini Naturals in Chicken is the best all-round pick. Milk-Bone Original Biscuits are the best budget pick, and Blue Buffalo BLUE Bits are the best value training treat. Merrick Power Bites are the best grain-free option. Greenies Original Regular is the best dental chew here.
Before you order, confirm the flavor, size, and pack count, because the most common mistake is buying the wrong size of the right treat.
|—|—|
You might also like